What Each Principle Means at the Work Order
Make the work order useful to the person who reads it next. A clear calibration record lets a reviewer follow the original result, any adjustment, and the decision that followed. ALCOA+ gives your team a practical way to examine that record together.
The record should carry the explanation forward. Start where the procedure, person, instrument, and result meet, then follow the information through correction, review, and retention.
How to read this guide: Source principles retain their issuer’s scope. Work-order questions and exercises are practical applications for your approved procedures, not a regulator-issued checklist or a software certification.
Keep the terminology precise. FDA’s final December 2018 Data Integrity and Compliance With Drug CGMP Q&A uses ALCOA: attributable, legible, contemporaneously recorded, original or a true copy, and accurate. The guidance applies to drugs, including biologics.
ALCOA+ adds complete, consistent, enduring, and available. It appears in MHRA’s March 2018 guidance, PIC/S PI 041-1, effective July 1, 2021, and WHO TRS 1033 Annex 4, published in 2021. MHRA’s guidance does not extend to medical devices. Use each source alongside the record requirements applicable to your operation.
Use these questions to review maintenance and calibration records with the people who create, review, and preserve them. The principle definitions come from FDA’s 2018 guidance, MHRA’s 2018 guidance, PIC/S PI 041-1 §7.5, and WHO’s 2021 guideline.
| Principle | Question at the Work Order | Practical Check |
|---|---|---|
| Attributable | Can we identify who performed and recorded the activity? | Follow the person or account associated with the entry, correction, and review. |
| Legible | Can an authorized reviewer understand the record? | Check units, asset identifiers, instructions, attachments, and exported content. |
| Contemporaneous | Does the record represent when the activity happened? | Distinguish execution, entry, correction, and synchronization times where relevant. |
| Original or a true copy | Are we retaining the original information or a copy that preserves what is necessary? | Compare the retained record with its source and relevant context. |
| Accurate | Does the record faithfully represent the work and result? | Review readings, units, calculations, transcription, and corrections. |
| Complete | Is the information needed to understand the activity still present? | Follow the original result, any repeat or adjustment, supporting attachments, and disposition. |
| Consistent | Can the sequence and relationships be followed? | Review chronology, identifiers, and the relationship between entries and changes. |
| Enduring | Will the record remain intact through its required retention? | Examine storage, preservation, and access through system changes. |
| Available | Can authorized people retrieve and use the record when needed? | Retrieve a representative historical record and the context needed to interpret it. |
For drug-CGMP laboratory instruments, 21 CFR 211.160(b)(4) governs the calibration program. It includes suitable intervals, directions, schedules, accuracy and precision limits, and remedial action. It also prohibits use of instruments that do not meet established specifications. The requirement for complete periodic calibration records sits in §211.194(d).
Those are different questions: What program governs the instrument, and what does the record show happened under that program?
As a practical review, follow a calibration that involved an adjustment. Identify the as-found result before the adjustment and the as-left result afterward. Check whether the retained record explains what changed and what review or disposition followed. Keep the earlier result and the resolution connected.
The same review principle is useful in maintenance. A completed work order should make the work intelligible. If a technician found a condition requiring follow-up, the reviewer needs to see how that observation connects to the eventual decision. Review that connection using the completeness and accuracy principles in the source guidance.
FDA’s Records and Reports Q&A, Question 4, dated August 3, 2010, addresses electronic records from computerized laboratory systems and printed chromatograms. In that context, the printout does not retain all the information in the electronic record. FDA explains why the electronic records must be retained under the predicate rules.
Completeness is the test: An adequate copy preserves the information needed to understand the source record. MHRA’s March 2018 guidance §6.2 and PIC/S PI 041-1 §7.7 address preservation of data and the circumstances in which a copy retains the necessary information.
For a maintenance or calibration workflow, apply that distinction by comparing the source record with the exported version. Ask what a reviewer can no longer see after export. The missing information might include a correction history, an attachment, a relationship between records, or information needed to interpret a result. Use the components your workflow actually creates.
For drug CGMP records, §211.180(d) addresses originals, true copies, and other accurate reproductions. Evaluate the retained information against that requirement, including the context needed to interpret it.
A mobile workflow can involve several events: performing the work, recording the result, making a correction, and synchronizing with the central system. Review how your intended workflow preserves their meaning and sequence. Keep the time of the work distinguishable from the time of synchronization.
A useful internal exercise is to capture a test record offline, reconnect, and inspect the resulting history. Then introduce a conflicting change through the approved test process and follow its resolution. Evaluate the behavior against your requirements and procedures.
For records in Part 11 scope, the relevant audit-trail and signature provisions remain attached to the record. Evaluate those controls throughout capture, transfer, and retrieval.
Use this allocation to start the conversation, then assign the actual responsibilities in your approved procedures.
| Responsibility | Suggested Discussion Owner | Evidence to Review Together |
|---|---|---|
| Record the work and explain corrections | Technician or person performing the activity | Executed record, source information, and relevant history |
| Review calibration context | Metrology | As-found and as-left data, applicable limits, and the disposition |
| Review work completion and follow-up | Maintenance | Work performed, unresolved observations, and equipment status |
| Define record-review and exception procedures | Quality | Review evidence and the basis for decisions |
| Preserve access, history, and availability | IT or system owner | Access administration, retrieval behavior, and change records |
The practical value is in the handoff. Agree who recognizes a missing attachment, who investigates an unexplained correction, and who decides whether a record is ready for its intended use. Review the arrangement against the lifecycle focus in MHRA’s 2018 guidance, PIC/S PI 041-1, and WHO’s 2021 guideline.
Select a representative completed work order through your internal review process. Include a record with a correction or exception when useful; a clean example alone may leave important behavior unexplored.
Record what the sample showed and use it to improve the workflow you reviewed. The exercise applies the principles in FDA’s 2018 guidance and PIC/S PI 041-1 to a bounded sample.
FDA‘s final December 2018 Q&A uses ALCOA. Attribute ALCOA+ to MHRA, PIC/S, and WHO when discussing their guidance, with the relevant scope identified.
Evaluate whether the retained copy preserves the information needed for the applicable requirement. FDA’s August 3, 2010, Question 4 explains why printed chromatograms are incomplete in the laboratory-system context it addresses. Review your proposed copy against 21 CFR 211.180(d) and the PIC/S true-copy guidance in PI 041-1 §7.7.
An audit trail can help explain changes, but completeness also depends on the information the activity requires. As a practical review, check the executed record, relevant source information, exceptions, and review evidence together. Assess the record as a whole, including the information needed for its intended use.
Start with a record your team uses to make a decision. Ask whether another authorized reviewer can follow the work, changes, and disposition using the retained information. Then extend the review based on what you learn.
Bring Maintenance, Metrology, Quality, and IT together around the same work order. Agree what each person needs to see and who owns the remaining gaps.
Next, test whether another authorized reviewer can retrieve and explain the complete package. Use the rehearsal and retrieval log in Audit-Ready EAM/CMMS Records.
Evaluating software to support these records? The EAM Buyer’s Guide includes questions on record integrity, calibration failure handling, and electronic signatures, plus a scenario for reviewing a signed record outside the application.
Get the EAM Buyer’s Guide. For the wider equipment-record and software-evaluation context, return to The GMP Playbook for EAM/CMMS.